When a landlord proposes a rent increase, the choice is not simply “higher rent or lower rent.” Use this lease renewal decision worksheet to compare the full cost of renewing with the full cost of moving, including utilities, deposits, fees, commuting, moving expenses, concessions, lease length, maintenance concerns, and the value of flexibility.
Overview
Deciding whether to renew your lease or move requires more than comparing the advertised monthly rent on two apartments. A cheaper listing may involve a longer commute, higher utility costs, application fees, a new security deposit, or immediate moving expenses. Meanwhile, renewing may provide stability but lock you into a higher payment or leave unresolved maintenance and space concerns.
The most useful comparison has two parts:
- Total cash cost: the money you expect to spend during the comparison period.
- Practical value: the benefits and drawbacks that are difficult to express as a precise dollar amount, such as flexibility, reliability, location, privacy, storage, and the condition of the home.
For a clean comparison, use the same period for both choices. A 12-month comparison is usually easy to understand, but you can also compare the actual lease length being offered. Record assumptions separately so you can update the worksheet when a landlord changes the terms or a new rental listing becomes available.
Before deciding, check your existing lease, the renewal notice, and any applicable local tenancy rules. Notice periods, deposit terminology, fee limits, and rent-increase requirements can vary by location and by lease type. Treat the worksheet as a planning tool, not a substitute for reviewing the documents that govern your tenancy.
How to estimate
Start by calculating the cost of renewing, then calculate the cost of moving into a realistic alternative. Use this basic formula for each option:
Comparison-period cost = recurring monthly costs × number of months + one-time costs − confirmed concessions or credits
For recurring monthly costs, include:
- Base rent
- Average electricity, gas, water, internet, and other utilities paid by the tenant
- Required parking, storage, amenity, pet, or service fees
- Transportation or commuting costs that change because of the location
- Regular household costs that are directly affected by the property, such as paid laundry or required rubbish services
For one-time costs, include:
- Moving labor, truck hire, packing supplies, cleaning, and temporary storage
- Application, screening, administration, or holding fees
- Utility connection or transfer charges, if applicable
- The portion of a new deposit that requires additional cash upfront
- Expected lease-break, notice, or overlap costs, if your current agreement allows or requires them
Separate a deposit from a true expense. A refundable deposit may not reduce your long-term cost, but it can affect how much cash you need at move-in. Record it as an upfront cash requirement, and record any nonrefundable deductions or fees as costs only when they are known or reasonably estimated.
Then compare the difference:
Move-versus-renew difference = total moving cost − total renewal cost
A positive result means moving costs more in the comparison period. A negative result means moving costs less, based on the information entered. Do not stop at the calculation: review the nonfinancial factors before treating a small difference as decisive.
Inputs and assumptions
Copy this worksheet into a note or spreadsheet and fill in both columns.
| Input | Renew | Move |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly rent | ||
| Monthly utilities | ||
| Monthly required fees | ||
| Monthly commuting or transport cost | ||
| Lease length in months | ||
| Moving and cleaning costs | Usually 0 | |
| Application or administration fees | Usually 0 | |
| Additional deposit cash required | ||
| Overlap or lease-break costs | ||
| Confirmed concessions or credits | ||
| Total comparison-period cost |
Use actual figures where possible. If you do not know a utility amount, use a reasonable range rather than a falsely precise number. For example, calculate a low, expected, and high case for seasonal electricity or commuting. Mark estimates clearly and replace them when you receive bills, written offers, or a complete lease proposal.
Also score each option on a simple 1-to-5 scale for condition, maintenance responsiveness, location, noise, space, safety comfort, access to transport, and flexibility. A home with recurring repair concerns should not be treated as equivalent to a well-maintained alternative merely because the monthly rent is similar. Keep a repair log and maintenance schedule if you need evidence for a renewal discussion; the rental property maintenance calendar can help organize that record.
For a new property, verify the listing details, total fees, utility responsibility, pet rules, parking terms, and available lease lengths before comparing it with your current home. A viewing checklist can help you inspect condition and document questions: see the home viewing checklist.
Worked examples
Example 1: Renewal is cheaper during the first year
Assume a tenant is offered a 12-month renewal at $1,850 per month. Utilities average $180, required monthly fees are $0, and the commute costs $120 per month. The renewal estimate is:
($1,850 + $180 + $120) × 12 = $25,800
An alternative apartment is advertised at $1,725 per month. Utilities are estimated at $190, required fees are $60, and the commute is expected to cost $180 per month. The tenant estimates $900 for moving and cleaning, $75 in application fees, and a $500 first-year concession:
($1,725 + $190 + $60 + $180) × 12 + $900 + $75 − $500 = $26,335
On these assumptions, moving costs $535 more during the first year. The new home could still be the better choice if it solves a serious maintenance problem, shortens the commute in other ways, provides needed space, or offers a lease length that better matches the tenant’s plans.
Example 2: A small monthly difference can change the result
Suppose renewing costs $100 more per month than moving, but moving requires $1,400 in upfront expenses. The monthly saving from moving is $1,200 over 12 months, leaving a first-year difference of only $200 before considering deposits, utility changes, or concessions. In this situation, the decision may depend more on condition, location, timing, and cash flow than on headline rent.
Record both the first-year result and the continuing monthly result. One-time moving costs may matter less if you expect to stay in the new home for several years, while a recurring rent or commuting difference becomes more important over time.
How to negotiate lease renewal
Ask for the proposed rent, lease length, included services, fees, and deadline in writing. If you want to negotiate, keep the request specific and practical:
“I would like to renew, but the proposed increase changes my budget. I have compared similar rental listings and my expected costs. Would you consider a lower monthly rent, a longer fixed term at a smaller increase, or a credit for documented maintenance concerns? Please let me know the best available terms and the date by which I need to decide.”
You can also ask whether a longer term, earlier decision, or renewal without added services changes the offer. Do not rely on a verbal promise; request the final terms in the renewal document. If the property has unresolved repair issues, attach a concise dated list and keep copies of communications.
When to recalculate
Revisit the worksheet whenever the underlying inputs change. Start at least early enough to meet your lease’s notice deadline, then update it when you receive a formal rent-increase or renewal notice. Check alternative apartments for rent and property listings using the same filters for location, size, fees, pets, parking, and lease length so the comparison is meaningful.
Recalculate when:
- Your rent, utilities, income, household size, or commuting pattern changes
- A renewal offer changes its rent, fees, concession, or lease length
- You find a realistic alternative rental listing
- Moving, storage, application, or deposit requirements become clearer
- Maintenance, noise, safety comfort, or space concerns materially change
- You are considering a roommate or shared-living arrangement
- Local tenancy rules or common lease-renewal practices change
Use a final three-step check: confirm the notice deadline, confirm the complete written cost of each option, and confirm that the choice fits your budget after recurring household expenses. Save the completed worksheet with your lease documents. It can be reused at the next renewal, after a rent increase, or whenever you compare a new rental with your current home.