When several buyers are competing for the same home—or when you are deciding what to put in your own offer—the highest price is only one part of the decision. This home offer comparison worksheet helps you assess price, financing strength, deposits, contingencies, timing, included items, credits, and risk in one repeatable format.
Overview
A purchase offer is a package of terms, not just a number. A lower offer with dependable financing, a workable closing date, and fewer unresolved conditions may be more attractive than a higher offer that depends on several events. Similarly, a buyer should not improve an offer by removing protections they cannot safely afford to lose.
Use the worksheet below for each property and label every item as confirmed, estimated, or unknown. That distinction prevents assumptions from being mistaken for firm terms. Contract names, disclosure rules, deposit deadlines, and contingency practices vary by location, so treat this as general educational guidance and check the applicable contract with a qualified local professional before signing.
Home offer comparison worksheet
| Offer term | What to record | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase price | Total amount offered and any escalation mechanism | Shows headline value, but not the seller's net proceeds or your total cost |
| Financing | Loan type, down payment, rate status, lender readiness, and cash strength | Helps assess whether the buyer can complete the purchase |
| Earnest money or deposit | Amount, payment date, holder, and refund conditions | Indicates commitment and creates deadline-sensitive risk |
| Inspection contingency | Inspection period, response options, and repair or cancellation rights | Defines how defects can affect the transaction |
| Appraisal contingency | Whether it applies and how a valuation gap will be handled | Addresses the risk that the property value does not support the price |
| Other contingencies | Sale of another property, title review, insurance, or other conditions | Reveals dependencies that could delay or end the deal |
| Closing date | Proposed date and flexibility window | Must work with moving, financing, possession, and the seller's next step |
| Included items | Appliances, fixtures, furniture, equipment, or other personal property | Avoids uncertainty about what remains with the home |
| Repairs and credits | Requested work, closing-cost credit, allowance, or price adjustment | Changes the seller's net and the buyer's cash needed at closing |
| Offer expiration | Date and time the offer remains open | Creates a decision deadline and may affect negotiation pace |
How to estimate and compare an offer
Start by calculating the buyer's estimated cash requirement. A simple planning formula is:
Estimated cash needed = down payment + closing costs + prepaid items + deposit due now − eligible credits
This is a planning estimate, not a final settlement figure. Confirm which costs are included, whether the deposit is credited toward the purchase, and whether a proposed seller credit is permitted under the financing and contract terms.
Next, estimate the seller's practical net:
Estimated seller net = purchase price − agreed credits − payoff obligations − selling costs
Do not assume that a credit has the same value as a price increase. A credit may help with eligible closing costs, while a higher price may increase the loan amount and affect appraisal or qualification. The value of each term depends on the transaction's financing, local practice, and contract language.
For competing offers, score each one in four separate categories:
- Economic value: price, credits, deposit, and expected net.
- Certainty: financing documentation, cash reserves, contingencies, and deadline realism.
- Timing: closing, possession, inspection, appraisal, and deposit dates.
- Fit: included items, occupancy needs, repair expectations, and communication quality.
Use a notes column for unresolved questions. An offer should not receive a favorable score simply because a blank field appears harmless; unknown terms are transaction risks until confirmed.
Inputs and assumptions
Before comparing offers, gather the documents and facts that support the entries. For a buyer, this may include a lender preapproval, proof of available funds, the planned down payment, a maximum comfortable monthly payment, and a realistic moving schedule. A mortgage affordability calculator can help with planning, but it should not replace the lender's qualification figures or a household budget.
For a seller, collect the desired closing and possession dates, the payoff information needed to estimate proceeds, known repair or disclosure matters, and a list of items that will remain. Decide in advance which terms are essential, which are negotiable, and which would create unacceptable risk.
Questions for each offer
- Is the financing type and loan amount clearly stated?
- Has the buyer shown funds for the down payment, deposit, and expected closing costs?
- When is the deposit due, and what happens if a deadline is missed?
- Does the inspection provision allow an appropriate review of the home's condition?
- What happens if the appraisal is below the offer price?
- Are the proposed credits allowed and supported by the buyer's closing-cost needs?
- Are the closing, possession, and move-out dates practical for everyone involved?
- Are appliances, fixtures, leased equipment, and other included items described precisely?
- What disclosures, title documents, insurance requirements, or local forms remain outstanding?
Keep a separate record of verbal statements. If a term matters, request that it appear in the written offer or an accepted amendment rather than relying on a conversation.
Worked examples
Assume a seller is comparing two offers on the same home. Offer A has a purchase price of 400,000 in the applicable currency, a 20,000 seller credit, a financing contingency, and the seller's preferred closing date. Offer B is 410,000, has no credit, but includes a shorter inspection period and a closing date that is difficult for the seller.
Offer B has the higher headline price, but its practical advantage is 10,000 before considering any costs or risks. Offer A may be preferable if the credit is usable, the financing is dependable, and the preferred timing has meaningful value. The seller should ask for the lender's confirmation of the credit, compare estimated net proceeds, and decide how much weight to assign to timing and contingency risk.
From the buyer's side, suppose the purchase price is 400,000, the planned down payment is 80,000, estimated closing and prepaid costs are 12,000, and eligible credits are 5,000. The planning estimate is:
80,000 + 12,000 − 5,000 = 87,000 estimated cash requirement
If the appraisal comes in below the price, the buyer may need additional cash, renegotiate, or use a contract right if one exists. That possibility should be discussed before weakening or removing an appraisal contingency. The example is intentionally simplified; actual amounts and remedies depend on the loan, contract, and jurisdiction.
When to recalculate
Revisit the worksheet whenever a core input changes. Recalculate after a lender changes the approved loan amount or rate, the buyer changes the down payment, a new inspection reveals repairs, the appraisal result arrives, or either party proposes a credit or price adjustment. Also update it when closing dates, possession plans, deposit deadlines, or included items change.
Before accepting or signing, read the complete written offer and compare it with the latest worksheet. Confirm every deadline, identify who holds the deposit, and verify how contingencies end or are waived. If multiple offers are being compared, use the same fields and assumptions for each one. Finally, obtain jurisdiction-specific legal, tax, lending, or real estate advice where needed. A clear comparison does not eliminate risk, but it makes the trade-offs visible before a decision becomes binding.